The future of the Wales Office. Need it all be so negative?
Posted on Monday, July 28, 2008 at 1:38pm
no responses
I have to admit that I don’t particularly see eye to eye with Elfyn Llwyd’s analysis as to why the Wales Office should not be reformed under new constitutional changes by Gordon Brown- i.e that “it would slow down the democratic process and hinder the work being done on LCOs [legislative competence orders]‘ and that ‘ it would be foolish to take this step at this moment in time. ‘
The Westminster Government has plans to introduce a new super department for the UK’s nations and regions. Whether Wales is classed as a region in this instance I’m not so sure, but the main thrust behind this particular change is the argument that it would serve to benefit devolution, not undermine it. I haven’t seen the plans in full, but I would tend to agree with Peter Black AMs analysis ( there’s a first!) in that the main concern lies with the status of any new super department, and the need for Wales to be fully represented in such a department. To do away with the current system of having a dedicated Secretary of State for Wales would be insufficient without taking this into account.
I am more flexible about changes to the Wales Office as I believe that it must evolve as devolution progresses. To leave it as it stands would be in denial of the system that we have in place at the moment, and the development of the Welsh Assembly to date. Of course, as I have said on so many occasions that I am now becoming bored of myself, the current LCO system was created by Labour for Labour, and the veto by the Secretary of State on new legislation brought forward by AMs still stands. I would be much more supportive of any ideas to change the make up of the Wales Office if Gordon Brown and his advisers scrapped this injustice, and gave the Assembly more flexibility to govern without strict caveats to power here in Wales.
The sooner we get a Parliament for Wales the less we will have to worry ourselves with the workings of the Wales Office. In my opinion, an office that combines the work of Northern Ireland, Wales and Scotland could be given the flexibility to be more progressive in that it may encourage those in the department to share cross border ideas on legislation, and encourage greater communication between the Celtic Nations.
We shall wait and see what comes of this idea.
